Buying guide

The Best Broadhead for Elk

Researched by Johnny Alto · Published July 21, 2026

How this guide was made: I don't own every product I write about, and I won't pretend otherwise. Unlike the hands-on reviews elsewhere on this site, this is a research pick, synthesized from bowhunting communities like Rokslide and r/bowhunting plus public owner discussions. It reflects the available research, not my own product testing. See how we research our picks →

Short answer: The best broadhead for elk is the G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead. The elk broadhead hunters recommend again and again. The main things to weigh are fixed blade toughness, deep penetration, reliable sharpness, and flies true.

Top pickG5 Outdoors Montec BroadheadView offer →

Top pick

G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead

The elk broadhead hunters recommend again and again. The G5 Montec is a one-piece 100 grain fixed head machined from a single piece of steel, so there are no blades to loosen or replace and nothing to fail on a heavy quartering hit through an elk's shoulder. The 1 1/16 inch cut and MIM steel construction are prized for deep, reliable penetration and easy resharpening. Tough, simple, and proven on elk, it is the durable standout for the money.

View on Amazon Editorial illustration.

Elk are big, heavy-boned animals, so the broadhead debate for elk comes down to penetration and durability: most experienced elk hunters run a tough fixed-blade head that drives through bone and stays intact, rather than a mechanical that can fail on a heavy hit. You want a strong ferrule, a sharp durable blade, and a design that flies true from your setup. Look for a rugged fixed head, reliable sharpness, and proven penetration.

How do the best options for broadhead for elk compare?

Pick	Product	Why it makes the list
Top pick	G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead	The elk broadhead hunters recommend again and again.
Compact fixed	QAD Exodus Swept Blade (125gr)	An ultra-short fixed head with a 1 1/4 inch cut that flies like a field point and hits hard, at 125 grains for a heavier, deeper-driving arrow. The compact design resists deflection on bone, a favorite for elk hunters who want fixed-blade toughness with easy tuning.
Blood trails	Muzzy Trocar Broadhead (100gr)	A 100 grain fixed head with a hardened Trocar tip and a 1 3/16 inch cut, known for breaking bone and leaving strong blood trails. A rugged, affordable classic that has taken plenty of elk when you want a big, tough cut.

What should you look for in broadhead for elk?

A few things separate a good broadhead for elk from a frustrating one: fixed blade toughness, deep penetration, reliable sharpness, and flies true. Weigh these before you buy.

Fixed blade toughness: a strong one-piece or short head that survives bone.
Deep penetration: the priority on heavy, big-boned elk.
Reliable sharpness: blades that hold and resharpen.
Flies true: a head that groups with your broadhead-tuned setup.

How the picks compare on specs

Spec	G5 Montec (pick)	QAD Exodus	Muzzy Trocar
Type	Fixed, one-piece	Fixed, short	Fixed 3-blade
Grain	100 gr	125 gr	100 gr
Cut	1 1/16 in	1 1/4 in	1 3/16 in
Strength	MIM steel, resharpen	Deflection-resistant	Trocar tip, bone-breaking

What are the best alternatives?

Compact fixed

QAD Exodus Swept Blade (125gr)

An ultra-short fixed head with a 1 1/4 inch cut that flies like a field point and hits hard, at 125 grains for a heavier, deeper-driving arrow. The compact design resists deflection on bone, a favorite for elk hunters who want fixed-blade toughness with easy tuning.

View on Amazon

Blood trails

Muzzy Trocar Broadhead (100gr)

A 100 grain fixed head with a hardened Trocar tip and a 1 3/16 inch cut, known for breaking bone and leaving strong blood trails. A rugged, affordable classic that has taken plenty of elk when you want a big, tough cut.

View on Amazon

Bottom line: the G5 Montec is the tough one-piece pick for elk; the QAD Exodus flies like a field point and the Muzzy Trocar breaks bone and bleeds well.

Our top pickG5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead

View on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

What is the best broadhead for elk?

G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead. The elk broadhead hunters recommend again and again.

What should you look for in broadhead for elk?

Focus on fixed blade toughness, deep penetration, reliable sharpness, and flies true.

What is a good alternative to the G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead?

The QAD Exodus Swept Blade (125gr). An ultra-short fixed head with a 1 1/4 inch cut that flies like a field point and hits hard, at 125 grains for a heavier, deeper-driving arrow. The compact design resists deflection on bone, a favorite for elk hunters who want fixed-blade toughness with easy tuning.

Related buying guides

This is a research-based buying guide, not a personal hands-on review. Product details, prices, and availability can change; confirm the current listing on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.

← More Guides: A–F · All guides · How we research · About · Affiliate Disclosure · Privacy Policy · Contact